An ivory sofa and walnut side table in a serene Bergen County living room, with dark-framed windows overlooking a quiet winter garden.

What Last Winter Says About Listing a Bergen County Home This December

November 19, 2026

In December 2025, a seller listing a single-family home in Bergen County competed with 599 other homes for sale across the whole county. Two months earlier, in October 2025, the count had been 1,008. That is the main reason a winter listing worked last year. Most other owners had taken their homes off the market or were holding them for spring, and the homes that remained still sold above list.

This November is different. The NJ REALTORS Local Market Update for October 2026 counts 1,166 single-family homes for sale in Bergen County, up 15.7% from October 2025. Months of supply is 2.8, up from 2.3. Sellers received 102.0% of list price in October 2026, compared with 102.6% a year earlier. Owners deciding between listing between Thanksgiving and February or waiting for spring are deciding in a market that starts the winter with more competition than last year's did.

December 2025 to February 2026, month by month

The table below takes the county's single-family figures from the official NJ REALTORS reports for December 2025, January 2026 and February 2026. October 2025 is included as the starting point.

Bergen County single-family Oct 2025 Dec 2025 Jan 2026 Feb 2026
Homes for sale 1,008 599 621 605
New listings 605 247 381 336
Closed sales 446 446 310 266
Median days on market 35 36 45 48
Percent of list price received 102.6% 102.6% 102.4% 101.2%
Median sales price $805,000 $827,139 $839,500 $750,000
Months of supply 2.3 1.4 1.5 1.4

Supply fell by about 40% between October and December and stayed close to 600 through February. Only 247 new listings came on the market in December 2025, the smallest monthly number in the table. A seller who listed that month was one of 247 new single-family listings across all of Bergen County.

The winter premium faded by February

A closed sale is recorded after its price was negotiated, so some of each month's closings reflect contracts signed in earlier weeks. The January and February figures come closer than December's to measuring deals made during the winter itself.

Those figures show a smaller advantage. Median days on market rose from 36 in December to 45 in January and 48 in February. The percent of list price received fell from 102.6% to 102.4% and then to 101.2%. February 2025 had recorded 102.7% and 41 days, so the February 2026 drop was not just the usual seasonal dip. Even with supply near its lowest point, homes went under contract in winter more slowly and for a smaller premium than in the fall.

February's median sales price of $750,000 was 10.2% below February 2025. That figure needs care. It is based on 266 closings, the fewest in the table, and a few lower-priced sales can move a median that small. Days on market and percent of list received are better measures here because they describe how deals were negotiated, not which homes happened to close. Both moved steadily in the seller's disfavor from December to February.

Last winter's low supply kept the typical sale above list in every month from December through February. Time on market still lengthened each month, and by February the premium over list was about half of what it had been in December.

This November starts from a higher floor

The October 2026 report shows the county going into winter with more homes for sale than at any point in the winter shown above. New listings in October 2026 were 691, up 14.2% from 605 a year earlier. Closed sales fell 9.2%, from 446 to 405. More homes came on the market and fewer sold, so inventory grew to 1,166.

A simple calculation shows what that means for December. Last year, inventory fell from 1,008 in October to 599 in December, or about 59% of the October level. If this year's 1,166 falls by the same share, roughly 690 homes would still be for sale in December 2026. That is about 90 more than the 599 a December 2025 seller faced, and more than any month in last winter's table. This is an estimate based on last year's seasonal pattern, not a forecast. The pattern itself has been steady: December 2024 had 632 homes for sale and February 2025 had 692, so the past two winters both stayed in a narrow range. This winter will probably start above that range.

The price data does not show weakness. The October 2026 single-family median was $880,000, up 9.3% from October 2025. The median for the first ten months of 2026 was $885,000, compared with $849,000 for the same period of 2025. Year to date, sellers received 103.8% of list price, almost the same as 103.9% a year earlier. Values are holding. What has changed is how much competition a seller faces at any given moment, and that shows up first in days on market and in the size of the premium over list. In October 2026, days on market reached 39, compared with 35 a year earlier.

Condos and townhouses are already selling below list

The same October report has a separate table for townhouses and condominiums, and that segment has moved further. Inventory reached 682, up 25.1% from 545 in October 2025. Months of supply rose to 3.9 from 3.0. Sellers received 99.3% of list price in October 2026, down from 100.6% a year earlier.

The townhouse-condo median rose to $582,000 from $501,000 over the same period, so in this segment too, prices held while terms changed. For an owner of a townhouse or condominium, the question this winter is less about getting above list and more about how close to list the final price will land. If single-family homes follow the same direction, the 102.0% October figure shows their premium has already started to shrink.

What this changes in a winter listing plan

None of this means a winter listing is a mistake. Last winter, 446 single-family homes closed in December, 310 in January and 266 in February, so homes kept selling through the cold months. What changes is the plan. Last winter's results came from low supply, and this year's supply is higher.

  1. Price against the current supply, not last winter's results. A December 2025 comparable sale closed when there were 599 competing homes. A December 2026 listing will likely face more. Comparables from last winter are useful for value, but their premium over list came from a level of scarcity that the October 2026 report does not show.
  2. If you plan to list in winter, list early in the window. Last winter, days on market and the premium over list both got worse each month from December through February. A home that is ready by early December goes on the market while the premium is at its strongest.
  3. Do the preparation before the holidays. Last winter's closings ran well below the fall's, so each showing counts for more. The work our Value-Up approach puts before a listing, including repairs, staging and photography, belongs before the first showing, because a short winter window leaves little room for a second launch.
  4. Treat days on market as the main signal. In thin markets, the number of days a home sits tells you more about pricing than the headline median does. Our Alpine post on days on market makes the same case for the county's highest-priced town. If a winter listing passes 39 days, the current county median, it is behind the market.
  5. Waiting for spring means more competition. Two years of December-to-February data show the county's lowest supply of the year falls in winter. A spring listing joins the season when new listings rise, and the October 2026 figures suggest more owners are already testing the market.

Your own town's figures may differ from these county-wide numbers. A Tenafly or Alpine listing priced in the millions behaves differently from a Bergen County median home, and our Bergen County neighborhood pages and home valuation cover what a county report cannot. The NJ REALTORS reports are archived by month, starting from lists like the one for December 2025, so you can check last winter's county figures against your own town's results.

If you are weighing a December or January listing against waiting for spring, Stacy Esser Group can help you price your home against the competition it is likely to face this winter and plan its preparation around the holiday weeks. Schedule a Meeting Today.

Your Trusted Partners

SEG is a high performing Bergen County luxury real estate team that blends relationship driven service, cutting edge marketing, and strategic negotiation to consistently outperform traditional agents.