Airy modern townhome dining area with a walnut table, ivory chairs, greige kitchen cabinetry and autumn foliage beyond a black-framed window.

At The Sylvan, Englewood Cliffs' Newest Townhomes Rent for Less Than the Houses Around Them Cost to Own

November 19, 2026

All 112 rental townhomes at The Sylvan on Sylvan Avenue are leased, and the property is taking names for a waitlist. Each is a three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath home of about 3,000 square feet. Interior units are listed from $8,795 a month and corner units from $10,700 to $11,000. At the mortgage rates in effect this month, every house in Englewood Cliffs that made Bergen County's weekly top-sales lists this summer costs more than that to own each month, before insurance or maintenance.

For an Englewood Cliffs seller, that gap matters as much as any nearby listing. The household that might buy a three- or four-bedroom house in the borough can now rent a new home of about the same size a few minutes away, with no down payment. The listing price has to account for that.

What 3,000 new square feet rents for on Sylvan Avenue

The Sylvan is Garden Communities' redevelopment of the former Unilever campus, at 1 Valentine Street off Route 9W. According to the developer's July 2026 release, the community will have 450 rental residences when it is finished: the 112 three-story townhomes plus a 338-unit apartment building where studios start at $2,700 a month. The first townhome residents had moved in by December 2025, and NorthJersey.com reported in June 2026 that the development was open and leasing.

The Sylvan's townhome page lists these figures:

  • Three bedrooms, 3.5 baths, roughly 3,000 square feet per home
  • Interior units from $8,795 to $9,000 a month, or about $105,500 to $108,000 a year
  • Corner units from $10,700 to $11,000 a month, or up to $132,000 a year
  • All townhomes leased, with the last two buildings expected "by March 2027 or later"

The renters are paying more than $100,000 a year to live in Englewood Cliffs in new construction. Owning in the borough costs more than that each month.

What this summer's closings cost to carry

NJ.com's weekly lists of Bergen County's most expensive sales included six Englewood Cliffs closings between June and August 2026. These are the borough's top-end trades, not a full sample. They do show what the upper part of the market cleared at this summer.

The estimates below assume 20% down and a 30-year fixed loan at 7.18%, the rate in Freddie Mac's Nov. 5, 2026 survey. The tax portion applies the borough's 2025 effective tax rate of 0.995% to each sale price. The county publishes that rate for comparing towns, not for computing bills, so the tax figure is a comparison yardstick. A real bill depends on the property's assessment. The first row uses the borough's 2025 average residential sale price of $1,832,097, across 42 sales, from the New Jersey Division of Taxation's 2025 residential statistics.

Property Closed Price Built Down payment Est. monthly principal and interest, plus tax at the effective rate
2025 borough average 2025 $1,832,097 about $366,000 about $11,400
26 Laurie Drive June 11 $2,499,999 1962 about $500,000 about $15,600
38 Geraldine Road July 30 $2,600,000 1961 $520,000 about $16,200
7 Jean Drive Aug. 28 $3,300,000 1999 $660,000 about $20,600
6 Allison Drive July 28 $3,750,000 2019 $750,000 about $23,400
577 Floyd Street Aug. 17 $3,850,000 2025 $770,000 about $24,100
74 Roberts Road July 7 $4,050,000 2012 $810,000 about $25,300

At the 2025 average price, the monthly cost of owning comes out close to the top of The Sylvan's townhome rents. At the price of a 1960s house on Laurie Drive or Geraldine Road, it runs about $4,600 to $7,400 a month above the townhome range, and the buyer also puts down half a million dollars. Laurie Drive sold at $730 a square foot and Geraldine Road at $634, for houses of 3,424 and 4,098 square feet. Those houses are about the size of a Sylvan townhome or larger. They are also six decades older.

Jumbo loans were priced a little higher. Mortgage News Daily's daily jumbo index read 7.37% on Nov. 9, so a buyer at these prices could face payments above the estimates in the table.

The tax rate narrows the gap

Most nearby towns can't match Englewood Cliffs on property tax. Bergen County's 2025 rate table puts the borough's effective tax rate at 0.995%. Tenafly's is 2.086%, Cresskill's 2.014% and Closter's 2.017%. Applied to a $2.6 million price as a comparison, the spread between 0.995% and Tenafly's 2.086% works out to roughly $2,360 a month. That figure compares the two towns. It does not estimate any household's bill. The county attaches a caution to the measure:

"The Effective Tax Rate is a statistical study that enables the comparison of one district to another district (based on assumption that all districts are at 100% valuation). This rate is NOT to be used to compute the tax bill."

The actual 2025 bill tells the same story. The state's 2025 figures show an average Englewood Cliffs residential tax bill of $15,880 across 1,902 residential line items, on an average assessment of $1,363,086. That works out to about $1,300 a month in tax on a house in a borough where the 2025 average sale was $1.83 million.

The low tax rate is why the gap between renting and owning in the table is a few thousand dollars a month at the lower end, not something closer to ten thousand. It narrows the difference. Mortgage payments at rates above 7% still keep it open.

Where a house earns its premium over the lease

A seller in the upper part of the market is asking a buyer to pay several thousand dollars a month more than The Sylvan's townhome rents. Several features of ownership account for that premium, and each can be shown in the listing:

  1. Principal paid down. On a $2.08 million loan at 7.18%, about $1,645 of the first month's $14,090 payment goes to principal. The rest is interest. Part of the gap in the table is money the owner keeps in the house.
  2. Size and land. Geraldine Road has about 4,100 square feet and Jean Drive about 4,900, against about 3,000 in a Sylvan townhome. The extra space and the yard have to be visible in the photos and the floor plan.
  3. Condition and age. The Sylvan is new construction. The top closings this summer were 577 Floyd Street, built in 2025, and Roberts Road, built in 2012, at $1,138 a square foot. A 1960s house is competing on price per square foot with a new home that comes with a lease.
  4. Availability. The townhomes are fully leased, and the last two buildings are expected by March 2027 or later. A house for sale this winter can be lived in sooner than the next Sylvan townhome opens up.

In the July post on Englewood Cliffs' two housing markets, we described how different parts of the borough's stock sell on different timelines. The Sylvan adds a third comparison, and it is quoted as a monthly rent instead of a sale price. Sellers above $2 million also owe New Jersey's seller-paid mansion fee, which we walked through in our Tenafly post on offers near the bracket lines.

Sylvan Avenue is adding more rentals

The Sylvan is unlikely to be the last rental comparison along Route 9W. The borough's Fourth Round affordable housing plan also includes:

  • Michaels Development Company's Cliffs on Hudson, 65 affordable rentals on Hudson Terrace, which was under construction as of the plan
  • A proposed mixed-use building by CFI Development at 20–32 Sylvan Avenue, with 48 apartments over ground-floor commercial space
  • Zoning capacity for up to 180 more residences on the remaining eight acres of 800 Sylvan

In March 2026, the borough adopted Ordinance 2026-06, creating Overlay Zone D along southern Sylvan Avenue. It allows 20 units per acre for residential development and 24 units per acre for mixed-use projects, each with a 20% affordable set-aside. Amendment 2026-19 was introduced Oct. 14 and passed on second and final reading Nov. 10. It adds a 35-foot, three-story height cap and requires at least 20% commercial floor area in mixed-use projects.

Office use on Sylvan Avenue is also changing. Samsung Electronics America said June 1 that it will move its U.S. headquarters from 700 Sylvan Avenue to Plano, Texas, with the transition expected by the end of 2026, according to NJBIZ. In a follow-up NJBIZ report, Mayor Park said, "We are confident that the strengths that attracted Samsung to Englewood Cliffs remain as strong as ever today."

FAQ

Is The Sylvan's rent the right comparison for a house that sold above $3 million? It is the closest new three-bedroom option in the borough, so it sets a floor on what a buyer at any price could pay to live there. At this summer's $3.75 million to $4.05 million closings, the estimated monthly cost of owning ran more than twice the top townhome rent. At Jean Drive's $3.3 million, it came close to double. Buyers at those prices are paying for land, size and newer construction, and the listing has to show all three.

Will lower mortgage rates close the gap? Lower rates reduce the principal and interest in the table. The tax and down payment parts barely change. Freddie Mac's 30-year rate eased from 7.32% on Oct. 22 to 7.18% on Nov. 5, 2026.

Can the effective tax rate tell me my own tax bill? No. The county says the effective rate is for comparing towns, and an individual bill is based on the property's assessment and the general tax rate.

The figures above are general estimates, not tax or financial advice. Your own loan terms and tax bill will differ, so confirm them with your lender and tax professional.

If you are planning an Englewood Cliffs sale, the Stacy Esser Group will build your pricing around the monthly comparison buyers are making today, using recent closings, The Sylvan's rents and current rates, and will stage the house to show what it offers over a lease. Start with a home valuation, then Schedule a Meeting Today.

Your Trusted Partners

SEG is a high performing Bergen County luxury real estate team that blends relationship driven service, cutting edge marketing, and strategic negotiation to consistently outperform traditional agents.