Tenafly NJ Neighborhoods: East Hill vs. Maugham vs. Stillman

If you’re thinking about moving to Tenafly, New Jersey or relocating within town, you’ll quickly learn that neighborhoods here are often defined by elementary school zones. While Tenafly is cohesive and community-oriented overall, each area offers a distinct lifestyle, housing mix, and neighborhood feel.

In this Tenafly neighborhood comparison, we’ll break down the three primary areas most buyers ask about:

• East Hill

• The Maugham School area

• The Stillman School area

This guide is designed to help you understand how each neighborhood lives day to day, so you can find the best fit for your lifestyle, not just a house.

East Hill: Estate-Style Living & Prestige

East Hill is often considered Tenafly’s most prestigious residential area. Known for its elevated topography and quiet, winding streets, this neighborhood offers a more private, estate-like environment.

What defines East Hill?

• Larger single-family homes on generous lots

• A sense of seclusion while still being close to town amenities

• A quieter, more residential pace of life

Architecturally, homes here range from classic colonials to custom-built properties with expansive layouts. Streets tend to be less dense, which appeals to buyers seeking privacy, space, and a more traditional luxury feel.

Who East Hill is ideal for?

East Hill often resonates with buyers looking for:

• More interior and outdoor space

• A calm, retreat-like setting

• Long-term ownership in a well-established neighborhood

While it’s slightly removed from the downtown core, many residents value that separation as part of East Hill’s appeal.

The Maugham School Area: Central, Walkable & Connected

The Maugham School area sits near the geographic heart of Tenafly and is often described as the town’s most centrally located and convenient neighborhood.

What defines the Maugham area?

• Close proximity to downtown Tenafly

• Easier access to shops, dining, parks, and community services

• A balanced mix of home styles and lot sizes

Homes here typically sit on more modest lots compared to East Hill, which contributes to a friendly, connected neighborhood feel. Sidewalks, shorter blocks, and proximity to everyday errands make this area particularly attractive for those who value walkability.

Who the Maugham area is ideal for?

This neighborhood often appeals to:

• Buyers who want to be close to downtown activity

• Households that enjoy walkable routines

• Those seeking a balance between space and convenience

If you like being near the center of town without sacrificing a residential feel, Maugham is often a strong contender.

The Stillman School Area: Community-Oriented & Approachable

The Stillman School area is frequently described as having one of the strongest neighborhood community vibes in Tenafly. Streets here often feel lively and social, with a welcoming, approachable atmosphere.

What defines the Stillman area?

• A mix of classic homes and thoughtfully updated properties

• Streets that encourage neighborly interaction

• Easy access to parks and local amenities

Homes in this area vary in size and style, making it appealing to a wide range of buyers. The layout and density naturally lend themselves to a more connected day-to-day experience.

Who the Stillman area is ideal for?

Stillman tends to attract buyers who value:

• A strong sense of community

• An active neighborhood feel

• Flexibility in housing styles and layouts

It’s a great option for those who want to feel plugged into Tenafly’s local culture and community life.

How to Choose the Right Tenafly Neighborhood

When deciding between these neighborhoods, consider:

• How important walkability and downtown access are to you

• Whether you prioritize space and privacy or neighborhood interaction

• Your preferred home style and lot size

Tenafly’s appeal lies in its ability to offer multiple lifestyle options within one cohesive town. Understanding these neighborhood nuances helps ensure your move aligns with both your current needs and long-term goals.

Final Thoughts: Finding Your Place in Tenafly

Whether you’re drawn to the refined feel of East Hill, the central convenience of Maugham, or the welcoming community vibe of Stillman, Tenafly offers a neighborhood that can truly feel like home.

If you’re exploring Tenafly real estate or considering a move within Bergen County, a neighborhood-focused approach is one of the best ways to narrow your search and make a confident decision.